Submissions to guix-patches keep increasing, but the rate at which they’re closed doesn’t quite keep up: (see “All bugs ever opened”)

How do #FreeSoftware projects encourage committers to review? Any insight to share?

#Guix thread:

(HT to zimoun)

@civodul The only direct help I know is to delegate to the CI as much as possible.

Having some feeling of friendship or kinship helps. It’s not just a common goal, it’s a group of people who like each other and feel that the review helps the others, too.

Other than that, and rather experimental: Aligning messaging to the core drivers of as many people as possible:

If you feel that reviewing supports something that gives you strength, that helps to become stronger.


@civodul One thing I also see is that it helps to have a web-based tool to flag something as ready to merge. That’s what I actually use on GitHub when I have a few minutes to review something: Read the diff, add tag ReadyForMerge.

· · Web · 1 · 0 · 0

@civodul That can especially help for small patches like this openjdk patch: /

What I’m missing here:
- CI information (do all packages still build? Is the coding style OK? — that could already be automatic feedback by email)
- if with patch: latest diff
- link to the issues-link in the acknowledgement email (the one to debbugs is in there) to make it easier to ask a friend for review
- button to mark a patch as ready for merge (with login).

Melde dich an, um an der Konversation teilzuhaben
Die Heimat für Rollenspieler ist eine Mastodon-Instanz für Rollenspieler und wird von der Rollenspiel-Community RollenspielMonster bereitgestellt. Wir bieten einen platz für Rollenspiel, Pen & Paper, Tabletop, TCG und vieles mehr. Die primären Instanzensprachen sind Deutsch.